Why Scoble Should Be Outraged — It’s NOT Patty Dunn

Source: saunderslog.com

Are you outraged by the actions of HP Chair Patricia Dunn.  A lot of people are, including Scoble.  Caught with her hand in the cookie-jar, so to speak, Patricia Dunn has been forced to resign over reasons of ethics and privacy.

Roll those big words around in your head for a minute.  Ethics. Privacy.

Patty Dunn is just the tip of the iceberg, and truth be told, what she did was undertandable albeit not legal.Â. Certainly one could argue that outing a leaky board member may have been the best thing for HP’s shareholders.

Robert, yo. oughta be a whole lot more outraged than you are, but not necessarily about Patty Dunn.  What you should be outraged about is that in Americ. you really have no ability to protect your privacy.  None.

Have you ever given out your social security number as identification.  For instance, to apply for credit.Â. With 10 minutes of searching on Google I learned how to obtai. your confidential credit report, and how to buy your social security number. I didn’t buy the report, but it certainly didn’t appear to be hard obtain that information.

That’s scary. Even so, it’. not nearly a. spooky as the implications of some of the everyda. things we all do.

Shop at Safeway, Albertsons or Costco.  Got a club card.  They know everything about how much you spend, and what you spend it on.  Maybe you’ve got a prescription for Lipitor, or any of a number o. other cholesteral reducing drugs that you fulfill at their pharmacy.  Maybe you also have a fondness for marbled beef and red wine.  Safeway knows.Â. What will they do with that information. 

As it turns out, Safeway’s privacy policy is pretty good.  They acknowledge that they collect all this information, tell you how they will use it, and further commit not to share it with anyone except law enforcement.

Safeway does not sell or lease personally-identifying information to any other non-affiliated company, person or agency. Safeway will disclose personally-identifying information only if required to do so by law, or if requested to do so by a law enforcement agency in the context of an ongoing criminal investigation where such disclosure could be required by subpoena, search warrant or court order. Such request for information must be cleared by our Legal Department.

Costco’s privacy policy, however, offers no such assurances. Costco’s policy includes this statement.

we may disclose personal information in the good faith belief that we are lawfully authorized to do so, or that doing so is reasonably necessary to comply with legal process or authorities, respond to any claims, or to protect the rights, property or personal safety of Costco Wholesale, our customers, our employees or the public. Information about our customers, including personal information, may be disclosed or transferred as part of, or during negotiations of, any merger, sale of company assets or acquisition.

You know what’s particularly scary about Costco.Â. Like Safeway. they sell the nicely marbled steaks, the wine to go with them, and the cholesteral reducing drugs.  But Costco also sells health insurance. They know about your medical risk profile, and whether you’re taking care of yourself.

Albertson’s collects the same data.Their privacy policy tells you what they’re doing with your information today, but makes no assurances that they won’t share it, other than to say that they won’t sell it. 

That’s your personal information.  But Albertson’s and Costco are basically saying that it’s their data, and they can use it any way they please.  Is that ethical?

Deal with a bank.  Maybe you’ve got an overworked credit card that you’d like to keep private. Work out at a gym with a trainer.Â. Maybe you’r. sensitive about your weight.  Buy books? How about that little book on dealing with … erectil. disfunction … you bought last month… could be embarrassing if tha. got out!

Virtually every business collects personal information. In fact, some businesses, like Safeway, make it impossible for you to get a fair price for goods unless you divulge that information.  “What.Â. You don’t want to pay $5/gallon for milk.  Just get a club card, sir“.  You should have a right to know how they use that information, and to opt out of their data collection process, without penalty. 

Legislation has helped to provide reassurances to the citizens of many countries.  For instance. in Canada all businesses are required to publish a privacy policy, and the law says that you may not use collected information for any purpose other than what is written in that policy.  The EU has similar rules. Those rules makes sense.  Voluntary compliance, which is what you have in the US, doesn’t make sense.

So, forget about Patty Dunn, Robert.  Instead, push for sensible limits on what data corporations can collect, and how they can use that data.  Push your lawmakers to enact safeguards that will really make a difference to ordinary people, everywhere. 

Published on September 23rd, 2006 under , ,


Last 20 posts tagged "sco"

Ascom Wireless Adds VoIP

Source: www.voip-news.com

-news.comAscom Wireless Solutions has added VoIP to the Ascom teleCARE IP solution. Intended for hospitals, the solution allows nurses to speak directly with patients when they call.
According…

Published on November 20th, 2008 under , , ,

EVENT: VoiceCon San Francisco 2008

Source: www.voip-news.com

-news.comVoiceCon San Francisco 2008 will be held at the Moscone North Convention Center from Nov. 10-13. The conference will also feature an exhibition of vendors with new and exciting products…

Published on November 5th, 2008 under , , , , ,

Tesco Launches a Very Interesting Mobile VoIP Play

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Earlier this week I alluded to the fact that Tesco would be coming out with a VoIP play that was based on their Freshtel acquisition as they’ve been selling FreshTel for sometime in the UK as…

Published on September 4th, 2008 under , , , , ,

Tesco Launches Mobile VoIP In Australia As FreshTel

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

While not a surprise to many in the Mobile VoIP space, Tesco has launched their Freshtel Mobile VoIP service in Australia.

Now here’s my speculation.

Australia is a wonderful market to tria…

Published on September 2nd, 2008 under , , , , , , , ,

Free WiFi In San Francisco, Taking Hold

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

What Earthlink couldn’t make work, Meraki is going to turn into reality.

Venture Beat reports that 100,000 people have logged on. This is a start…

Published on July 4th, 2008 under , , , , ,

Vulnerabilities? Avaya and Cisco Working On It

Source: www.voip-news.com

Vulnerabilities? What vulnerabilities?
That would have been the easy response for Avaya and Cisco when they were faced with a report exposing problems with their VoIP systems. But they didn’t…

Published on June 27th, 2008 under , , ,

Friday Links: Tesco/Freshtel, Skype

Source: www.voip-news.com

VoIP News of the UK reports on the Tesco/Freshtel deal. Read it here.
VoIP Watch has a reaction to Jim Courtney’s Skype Journal post on Tungle. Read it here.
Lucafiligheddu talks about reasons…

Published on May 23rd, 2008 under , ,

Vonage Put Under The Ikeroscope

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

I happen to always enjoy reading Ike Elliott’s analysis of companies in the VoIP space that are publicly traded. God does his microscopic analysis remind me of what we used to see from James…

Published on May 17th, 2008 under , , ,

Before You Buy Cisco Telepresence Have You Tried SightSpeed?

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Have you looked at the price of Cisco’s Personal Telepresence that was announced today?

$33,900 USD per seat

That’s 22 years worth of SightSpeed For Business for a ten (10) seat pack.

Granted…

Published on May 12th, 2008 under , , , , ,

Kimpton Hotel’s Palomar Hotel in San Francisco Has Pitiful Broadband

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

The other day Jonathan Greene posted about the lousy performance when it came to Broadband that he had at the Hotel Monaco in Seattle. The Monaco, like the Palomar here in San Francisco wher…

Published on May 4th, 2008 under , , , , , ,

Cisco’s Sales Force = AT&T

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Let’s face it. This is nothing new. For years one of Cisco’s channel partners has been SBC, Bell South and other now AT&T owned companies, working on the front lines as integrators as far…

Published on April 21st, 2008 under ,

Media Coverage on My AT&T / Starbucks Scoop Continues

Source: alanweinkrantz.typepad.com

While my focus of this blog has been on IPTV, I am starting to write and cover
stories about wireless. 
I happened to be driving in between my home
and my office, stopped at the Starbucks in…

Published on April 17th, 2008 under , , ,

Tandberg Links Up With Nortel to Battle Cisco in Telepresence

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

This is an example of a channel program. Tandberg has a telepresence suite to compete with Cisco.

Tandberg though doesn’t have the sales channel strength of a Cisco, so they go to a company…

Published on March 17th, 2008 under , , , ,

Wednesday Round-Up: Cisco Updates, Trouble at VoIP Inc., Manifone

Source: www.voip-news.com

Internet Storm Center warns that it’s time to update IP phones. Cisco Unified Communications has released a number of critical security updates to close-up vulnerabilities. Find out more her…

Published on February 13th, 2008 under , , , , , ,

Cisco Looking At Unified Communications, Video and More For Enterprise 2.0 World

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

David Greenfield at ZDNet has a wonderfully insightful post about Cisco’s moves to enhance their collaboration efforts in big ways.

What’s interesting is many of the moves they are making ar…

Published on February 8th, 2008 under , , , , , , , ,

Mobivox Gets Scobalized at CES

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Robert Scoble caught up with client Mobivox and their COO Nitzan Shaer at CES last week and gets the low down on Mobivox’s breakthrough calling service where calls between users are free regardless…

Published on January 18th, 2008 under , , , ,

Cisco Telepresence Goes Open

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Cisco took a page out of the book of Verizon and is making their Telepresence platform more open.

That means users of LifeSize and Tandberg HD systems will sometime next year become interoperab…

Published on December 10th, 2007 under , , ,

Big Win For Cisco

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Cisco wins a big partner in BT for their telepresence video conferencing solution…

Published on December 8th, 2007 under ,

Martin Geddes on the Skype London Fiasco

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Gotta love Martin’s ability to say so much, in so little.

This problem can be reversed.

All Skype has to do is pony up some cash. I mean after a 1.5 billion dollar right down, what’s a few…

Published on November 24th, 2007 under , , , , ,

Cisco Goes On The Road

Source: andyabramson.blogs.com

Cisco is taking their VOIP show on the road, in Ireland.

The idea of taking the technology opportunities to the customer isn’t new. But in this era where so many companies only excel in t…

Published on October 12th, 2007 under ,
Member of "Hype Media! Network"